Suhas Guruprasad

There are infinite isms

I'd like to believe that there are a finite set of -ism-s. But we'll see through a bit of formal modeling that this is probably infinite. What are the ones that we know of? The average person on the street would say capitalism, communism, socialism, and marxism. A somewhat educated person in the humanities would name a few more, they'd also say an -acy is also just an -ism, like democracy, plutocracy, meritocracy, and so on. But how many of them are there? We must explore mathematically.

Here is a simple model I propose. We'll start with F={f1,f2,f3,…} , where each element of the set F is an ideologum like f1 = private property is protected, f2 = banks may lend at interest, f3 = state plans industry and so on and so on. F is large but not infinite (or perhaps it is?). Then we can define an ism I as a subset of F. An even better way to think about it is that I is a closed set of propositions over F wherein we can say if f1 & f2 hold, f4 also holds. Thusly if |F|=ℵ0, then its power set has cardinality |P(F)|=2ℵ0. This gets pretty big pretty fast. Even if we discard all Is that are logically inconsistent, we will still have a very large number of consistent theories. Do we live in a Boolean algebra of subsets? or its Lindenbaum–Tarski algebra whose points form a compact totally disconnected Stone space?

To visualize this, let's consider a unit world of simple ideologums,

ℱ={p (Private property)b (Bank lending)s (State plans industry)c (Confucian morality)

Then 2F has 24=16 possible Is of which 14 Is are obviously neither capitalism nor communism. Assuming of course that there was some sort of a human council that sat in a roundtable somewhere in a castle in the mountains and decided which of f1, f2 ... fn goes to capitalism and which to communism. In our unit world above we'll simply say capitalism = {p,b}, Xi jinpingism = {p,b,s,c}, Maoism = {s}, for illustrative purposes. Since we model the I space as a high dimensional Boolean cube, there is continuum, natural neighborhoods and so on. We also have a structured way to travel the pathways and visualize one social reform after the other leading from one I to another I. Largeness aside, we can also explore this I space and its other properties further by considering (1) Distance, like Hamming or Jaccard distances on how many of the fs differ, (2) Commonality, with intersections and so on.